Cy Young vs Christy Mathewson

Cy Young vs Christy Mathewson

Cy Young vs Christy Mathewson

In a game billed as a pitchers' duel...

Boston Rustlers (who became the Braves) Cy Young and the New York Giants' Christy Mathewson face each other for the first and only time, before 10,000 Boston fans, the largest crowd of the year. At the time the Rustlers were 47.5 games out of first place.

Young gives up three homers and nine runs in less than three innings. With a 9 - 0 Giants lead, Manager John McGraw lifts Mathewson who pitched just two innings, preferring to save his ace for the pennant race against Chicago and Philadelphia. This would end up being the only time the two pitchers ever face each other. The Giants coast to an 11–2 win.

Young would go on to make 2 more starts in his professional career, winning the next start 1-0 over Babe Adams and the Pittsburgh Pirates and losing his final apperenace 13-3.

Mathewson went on to pitch for 5 more seasons, and his Giant's did make 3 more World Series apperences, including in 1911 vs the Philadelphia A's. The Giant's, however, lost all 3 World Series apperences as Matty went 2 - 5 in his starts despite giving up a a total of 11 earned runs.

Between the two pitchers they had 884 career victories, 155 shut outs and 1,184 complete games.

By The Baseball Page
Monday, 12 Sep 2011


More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

This day in baseball history

September 21

  • 1987

    On September 21, 1987, 40-year-old Japanese star Sachio Kinu ...

  • 1980

    On September 21, 1980, Steve Carlton of the Philadelphia Phi ...

  • 1970

    On September 21, 1970, Vida Blue of the Oakland A’s pitche ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Hal Trosky

1B, Cleveland Indians

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

Bucky Harris

2B, Washington Senators

Read Bio
Season Profile

2006 Boston Red Sox

There’s no way a t

Read Bio
Historical Figure

Rawlings Gold Glove


Read Bio
Manager Profile

George Wright

Boston Red Stockings

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile

Arthur W. Perdue

The Arthur W. Perdue Stadium

Read Bio
Babe Adams, Boston Rustlers, Christy Mathewson, Cy Young, John McGraw, New York Giants
Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: