Is C.J. Wilson a 4th starter on a championship team?

Is C.J. Wilson a 4th starter on a championship team?

Is C.J. Wilson a 4th starter on a championship team?

Someone in the Yankees organization thinks so in column by Joel Sherman in the NY Post. 

This statement caused a small stir after I quoted it in column about the Yankees offseason.

I am not a big fan of Wilson and certainly wouldn’t give him a multi-year deal, much less one for $100 million dollars. A week from now the Rangers may be World Series Champs and he is their ace, so you could argue that statement is primed to be blown away. Let’s forget the rhetoric and dive into the numbers.

In the spirit of full disclosure I haven’t seen Wilson pitch consistently, but his performance in last year’s ALCS and in the postseason this year has left me less than impressed.

Since entering the rotation last season, Wilson is a combined 31-15 with a 3.14 ERA. When you rank him amongst other starters his ERA+ of 140 is fifth in the American League. As a matter of fact, his number compare very favorably to Yankees ace CC Sabathia.

So should the Yankees let Sabathia and his ever expanding waistline walk and sign the younger and potentially cheaper Wilson?

During that two year period he’s made 28 starts against three of the poorer hitting teams in baseball; Seattle, Oakland, and Anaheim. In those starts he’s pitched 176 innings and allowed 60 earned runs for an ERA of 3.07. In his other 39 starts his ERA was 3.19. Not much of a difference, but his postseason performance is what concerns me the most. Going into the World Series, he is 1-4 with a 5.40 ERA in 7 playoff starts. Ultimately, he will be judged by the postseason if he pitched in New York.

It also is reasonable to assume that if the bright lights of the playoffs bother him, how will he handle Yankees-Red Sox, the Subway Series, and other games that are “events” when pitching here. Yes, he pitched well against the Yankees and Boston this year, but that is one start in a moment in time. He will be asked to potentially pitch 4 to 6 times against the Sox in a season. Big difference, especially with a lot on the line.

Its probably is harsh to call Wilson a “4th starter on a championship team;” the numbers don’t bear that out. I still wouldn’t feel comfortable investing $100 million in the guy if he can’t give you his best when you need it the most.

Wilson is a very good pitcher on a weak free agent market that will get top five starter money. Despite his two year run I don’t believe he is worth that kind of investment. And the fact that it’s just a two-year run should make teams wary as well.

This could be a case where we are underrating and overrating the player at the same time. Underrating his regular season, but the money that he will be paid for those 32 starts will not match up the performance necessary when the lights shine the brightest.

Due to the Yankees history with Carl Pavano, A.J. Burnett, and Jaret Wright I would simply stay away.

By Mike Silva
Wednesday, 19 Oct 2011


More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

This day in baseball history

October 02

  • 2009

    B.J. Upton is the first player in Tampa Bay history to hit f ...

  • 2004

    The Montreal Expos earn the last win in the franchise's hist ...

  • 1978

    Bucky Dent's unlikely home run helps the New York Yankees de ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Dave Giusti

P, Houston Astros

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

Sam Thompson

3B, Detroit Wolverines

Read Bio
Season Profile

2007 Boston Red Sox

The Red Sox had been

Read Bio
Historical Figure

Juiced: Wild Times,

Juiced: Wild Times, Rampant

Read Bio
Manager Profile

Maury Wills

Los Angeles Dodgers

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile

Ames Field

Ames Field was a multi-purpose

Read Bio
No votes yet


  • west_life said: I agree with this post. But somehow, there must be something in him that the organization have seen to make that deal with him. - Lindsay Rosenwald 12:11AM 03/12/14
  • Mike Lavery said: I agree in the fact that CJ is both under and over rated. He's over looked by fans but he might end up having John Lackey syndrome, the best player in a weak free agent class. I wouldn't want to be the team that gives him that contract. He's younger than CC but only by 1 year. I'd rather have CC and his weight problem than CJ and him small starter sample size in an easy division. 3:41PM 10/20/11
  • Tom Hannon said: If there is one thing we know, the Yankees will have no problem over paying, as will Boston for pitching. Between the two teams there is but 1 true ace, and combined they have spent over $500 million dollars. 9:08AM 10/19/11
Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: