TheBaseballPage.com

Evaluating WAAS, WAR As HOF Measuring Sticks

Evaluating WAAS, WAR As HOF Measuring Sticks

Evaluating WAAS, WAR As HOF Measuring Sticks

The results of this year’s Hall of Fame voting and with them a renewed debate about what actually makes a worthy candidate. This debate has been around for decades, before the question of steroids arose, and has more to do with voting on “very good players,” you know, the guys who are at the top of the league but not necessarily among the best ever. A wide range of opinions exists as to who should be enshrined in the hall. I personally am in the camp that says that only the best of the best of the best should be in Cooperstown. I feel that if someone is a “borderline candidate” then they fairly certainly don’t belong. I think there are too many members of the Hall and that guys like Andre Dawsins, Jim Rice and Bruce Sutter were very good but not worthy of the company of Babe Ruth, Willie Mays etc. In an effort to really hash out who is deserving and who isn’t, new age stats like WAR (Wins Above Replacement) are often used. WAR has some problems however and in an effort to address them, ESPN’s Peter Keating devised WAAS (Wins Above All Star Level). Let’s take a brief look at how they do:

WAR gives players credit for wins above a replacement level player. It’s a very useful stat and maybe the best of the sabermetric era. The problem with using it in a HOF context is that it rewards compilers. The longer a guy’s career, the higher his career WAR (presumably if he’s a HOF candidate) simply by virtue of throwing together more and more positive WAR seasons. To fix this problem, WAAS takes into account the 2.5 WAR average of your typical All Star and gives credit for particularly great seasons (somehow).

The problem? WAAS doesn’t really accomplish its goal. Sure, by subtracting 2.5 from everyone’s WAR total we narrow the field to better players but guys can still cobble together impressive WAAS totals without doing anything special. For instance, look at Brian Jordan. He has a career WAAS of 13.5 which is nice but really Brian Jordan shouldn’t even register on any HOF evaluation stat. According to Keating, a WAAS of about 25 is a pretty good indication of HOF entry. By that measure, though,  Jeff Bagwell is almost qualified two times over (45.2 WAAS) and Dale Murphy (24.1 WAAS) should probably get in even though he only received about 12% of the vote this year.

Maybe the issue is just the level Keating set, maybe it should be higher. But I don’t think that’s the major problem. Perhaps, there is no stat to identify who is a potential HOFer and who isn’t. Maybe the value of WAR and WAAS is in comparing potential candidates to one another. WAAS can be extremely important for pitting people we’ve anecdotally identified as possible HOF members against one another but that’s the catch, we have to figure out who the guys are on our own.

-Max Frankel

By Off The Bench
Monday, 16 Jan 2012

 

More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

This day in baseball history

May 29

  • 1990

    On May 29, 1990, Rickey Henderson of the Oakland A’s becom ...

  • 1976

    On May 29, 1976, Houston Astros pitcher Joe Niekro hits the ...

  • 1972

    On May 29, 1972, former major leaguer Morris “Moe” Berg ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Kim Andrew

2B, Boston Red Sox

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

Hack Wilson

OF, Philadelphia Philies

Read Bio
Season Profile

1986 World Series Ne

1986 World SeriesThe

Read Bio
Historical Figure

Hank Aaron

 

Read Bio
Manager Profile

Rogers Hornsby

St. Louis Cardinals

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile

Arlington Stadium

The stadium was built in 1965

Read Bio
Your rating: None Average: 2.5 (2 votes)

Comments

  • belloabito said: Very good! Very much!abiti da sera economici 5:26AM 05/29/15
  • kepandaian said: I m always looking for information about each country and will follow and read always. Obat Penurun asam lambung obat amandel alami Oabt kencing berdarah 4:33AM 05/28/15
  • kepandaian said: I m always looking for information about each country and will follow and read always. Obat Penurun asam lambung obat amandel alami Oabt kencing berdarah 4:06AM 05/28/15
  • diniriani said: semoga yang baik selalu menyertai kita semua amin obat herbal radang amandel 4:43AM 05/26/15
  • diniriani said: cara mengobati amandel tanpa operasi dgn konsumsi obat herbal amandel 4:20AM 05/26/15
  • diniriani said: cara mengobati tumor jinak tanpa operasi dgn konsumsi obat herbal tumor jinak 4:03AM 05/26/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Cara Pemesanan Ace Maxs 3:43AM 05/26/15
  • diniriani said: semua nya pasti bisa amin.. makasih yaa sdh berbagi info.. obat herbal batu empedu 3:22AM 05/26/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Manfaat Madu 3:21AM 05/26/15
  • pandoraz said: An account of two film fads

    There is definetly a quiet reorganising of movie basics happening.Two occurrences lately would underline as much.

    First, telugu superstar mahesh babu has plainly sought remake rights of jolly llb, bollywood's freshly released crossover hit.Second, himmatwala, the most recent biggie fashioned out of what we call the madras cut, consists of tanked.

    Far from being the 200 crore runaway success that director sajid khan had pompously promised, the 70 crore film may not even work worth half that amount.

    Is the influence of southern masala on bollywood witnessing audience fatigue at a time when south indian mainstream is waking up to realistic pastime?

    Jolly llb, a satire seeped in realistic look, is the last film you'd expect for an advertisement remake down south, a film factory that thrives on its larger than life brand of home theatre.

    The 15 crore arshad warsi film did business of over rs 31 crore(And depending), Opening in the wake of several crossover releases that have emerged as small to medium hits this year, Specifically Kai Po Che, Saheb Biwi Aur mobster Returns and Special 26.

    Specific, even as race 2 and himmatwala the only two mass mainstream releases in the first quarter fared below requirement.

    Positive, race 2 and himmatwala still gross many more than any crossover hit.And a well hyped big release flaunting a top hero will excite the trade more than a crossover winner.

    Products, the biggies have five times your capacity to purchase too, splurging on formation, star cast and special promoting and advertising.They also enjoy a wider release across minimum 3, 000 3, 500 screens or even more.

    The no show of himmatwala proves an area, even alplanned.Over the top entertainment will continue to count for the film trade, but viewers won't accept junk in the name of commercial cinema.

    It isn't http://vlwn-ofl.de/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=30 prudent anymore for bollywood to automatically assume that any mega budget bilge riding a star cast is for you to become a blockbuster.

    As opposed, the multiplex culture has generated space for limitedbudget films to make profit.These films are not contenders for the fabled 100 crore club, but they assure good returns for vendors and sustain the trade overall.

    The recent crossover hits define the second model of indie films in bollywood.Not since the parallel cinema movement of the seventies have so many bright brains combined efforts to serve quality.

    While the seventies swing was more the actual arthouse, the current crop aims at sensible theater.

    Mahesh babu's interest in jolly llb proves that the slant http://ansapinc.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=55 at sensible entertainment is not on a bollywood alone.These small films have acquired an exposure in their own business.

    Now all that they need is a serious platform for attraction.An annual awards ceremony precisely to toast the genre would perhaps encourage the makers to push limits, in the lines of robert redford's annual sundance gala in america alone.

    It's possible that anurag kashyap, the man who kickstarted bollywood's currently growing crossover streak, should start a program for a desi sundance.

    Old fire hearth die hard

    Ranbir kapoor and as a consequence deepika padukone.

    Are ex lovers better at igniting the sparks if it makes them reunited in a casting coup than real life lovers or regular co stars?If you have watched ranbir kapoor and deepika padukone in early promos of yeh jawaani hai deewani(In photo), You may tend to agree.The main time flames, who insist they happen to be just friends now, have surely resurrected a percentage of old heat.

    Ranbir and deepika are not a one-Time case.Yr after, when katrina kaif taken back with salman khan in the spy romance ek tha tiger, most people noted how both stars have also been on a ball together.Salman has never gelled so well with any other co star recently as he did with rumoured ex girlfriend katrina in the blockbuster.An enjoyable poll subsequently revealed that katrina was still the popular choice as the right girl for salman, so what if she is said to be dating ranbir kapoor now and only is still"Buddys"Collectively ek tha tiger co star.

    Once bitten is clearly not a case of being shy for our stars especially in regards getting the chemistry right.

    Fox components the x men to japan

    Hugh jackman starrer the wolverine by 20th century fox is most current x men film.

    When hugh jackman bares his mutant super hero claws again in http://www.gauchofierro.es/en/?option=com_content&view=article&id=13 the wolverine this july, he will be in to many blood curdling yakuza action.The actual brand new film of the x men series sees the aussie hunk, by means of wolverine, visit japan, and the oriental link to the tale does not end with fighting styles loaded stunts.

    Jackman's co star in the wolverine will probably be the hottie tao okamoto, the public presence of ralph lauren in her country.Movie makers 20th century fox, must be gunning to expand the far east market of the x men saga.

    The wolverine is that it is shot in 3d and is directed by james mangold, who last made the tom holiday tour http://atlas-co.ir/index.php/en/?option=com_content&view=article&id=67 cameron diaz hit, dark night and day.

    Russell crowe http://mip.faperta.unri.ac.id/2007/05/ralph-laurenhttpwww-ycol-co-uk-joe-at-all/ games the title role in darren aronofsky's noah.

    God is tremendous.Furthermore, artist is betting over $1, 000 million on her.Major studios have a string of biblical films aligned.

    3:17AM 05/26/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Manfaat Bunga Rosella 3:07AM 05/26/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Manfaat Pepaya Untuk Kesehatan 2:50AM 05/26/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Cara Pemesanan Ace Maxs 2:09AM 05/26/15
  • diniriani said: buat pria ataupun wanita yang sedang tertimpa penyakit sipilis yuu coba di ikhtiarin dgn konsumsi obat herbal sipilis 12:42AM 05/26/15
  • diniriani said: artikelnya bermanfaat dan bermutu neh.. yang butuh obat herbal benjolan sini merapat di obat herbal benjolan di leher tanpa operasi 12:16AM 05/26/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Pantangan Paru Paru Basah 12:12AM 05/26/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Pantangan Makanan Penderita Stroke 11:26PM 05/25/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Pantangan Makanan Penderita Stroke 11:23PM 05/25/15
  • diniriani said: anda punya keluhan bronkitis ??? coba yuk di ikhtiarin dengan konsumsi herbal acemax ini.. #yukk mendekaat obat herbal bronkitis 11:20PM 05/25/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Manfaat Olahraga Untuk Kesehatan 10:56PM 05/25/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Obat Infeksi Saluran Pernapasan 9:50PM 05/25/15
  • diniriani said: ini kunjungan pertama aku lho.. so salam kenal ya buat tuan rumah nya :) obat herbal radang selaput otak 9:34PM 05/25/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Tips Mencegah Demam Berdarah 4:37AM 05/25/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Khasiat Kulit Manggis Untuk Kesehatan 11:39PM 05/24/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Pantangan Makanan Untuk Penderita Kanker Serviks 11:20PM 05/24/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Tips Menyembuhkan Kelenjar Tiroid 11:05PM 05/24/15
  • susan2 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Cara Mengobati Keputihan 10:57PM 05/24/15
  • uchiha said: http://kolodit.blogspot.com/ 2:29AM 05/24/15
  • susan1 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Cara Mengobati Ambeien 4:52AM 05/23/15
  • susan1 said: Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings. Legalitas Ace Maxs 4:40AM 05/23/15
Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: