Who ever heard of Bill Shettsline? Folks around the front office, and possibly a few of the players knew him; he was the club secretary. And then, he was the team field manager. On June 17, after a humiliating 16-4 pasting by the New York Giants had dropped the team to 19-27, President Al Reach fired manager George Stallings and tapped Shettsline, who had never played an inning of professional baseball, to be the Phillies’ new manager. The players had threatened to mutiny and refuse to continue play under the abrasive, 29–year-old Stallings, whose nickname, “Gentleman George” was obviously coined as an ironic thrust. To everyone’s surprise, Shettsline turned out to be a good manager; his 1889 Phillies finished the season at 78-71, in 6th place, and he continued to manage the team for four more years, compiling a 367-303 record. In 1905 Shettsline purchased the team and sold it in 1909.

One of the things Shettsline did was establish a four-man pitching rotation, much to the benefit of rookie lefthander Wiley Piatt who was 4-4 under Stallings, but 20-10 under Shettsline with six shutouts, tied for the league lead with Cleveland righthander, Red Powell. Two of Piatt’s shutouts were by 1-0 scores, and two were 2-0. Typically, Piatt pitched to the game situation, when his team scored many runs he was likely to allow many, but mostly not enough to lose.

Another rookie to light up the 1898 Phyllis’ sky was 22 year-old outfielder Elmer Flick who was elected to the Hall of Fame in 1963. Flick hit .302 in his rookie year with a .430 on base percentage. After four years learning his trade as a Phillie, Flick jumped to the newly-formed American League in 1902 and became a star with Cleveland. Nap Lajoie played second base and led the Phillies in homeruns and RBIs in 1898, outperforming Ed Delahanty. Lajoie, like Flick, fled the Phillies in 1902 for the American League. When the what if? game is played in Philadelphia, the names of Lajoie and Flick should head the list of guys who might have affected the history of the franchise in positive ways had they completed their careers as Phillies. Billy Hamilton was the first; there would be more.

By max blue

More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

This day in baseball history

October 31

  • 2010

    In game four of the 2010 World Series, the Giants beat the R ...

  • 2005

    Boston Red Sox general manager Theo Epstein resigns, a stunn ...

  • 2001

    Joe Falls of The Detroit News is voted the J.G. Taylor Spink ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Larry Walker

LF, Colorado Rockies

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

Harry Hooper

OF, Boston Red Sox

Read Bio
Season Profile

2004 New York Yankee

After losing the 200

Read Bio
Historical Figure

Baltimore Elite


Read Bio
Manager Profile

George Davis

Chicago White Sox

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile

PNC Park

Home of the National League's

Read Bio
Bill Shettsline, Elmer Flick, Nap Lajoie, Philadelphia Phillies, Wiley Piatt


    Be respectful, keep it clean.
Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: