TheBaseballPage.com

Projecting the Phillies' Opening Day Roster

Projecting the Phillies' Opening Day Roster

Projecting the Phillies' Opening Day Roster

The entire Phillies squad is down in sunny Clearwater (those jerks), meaning baseball season has arrived. We know the names and the faces, but now we need to find them places. Let’s try to figure out who will make the Phillies 25 man roster.

Most teams go with a staff of 12 pitchers (5 starters and 7 relievers) and 13 position players, but with inning eaters like Halladay, Lee, and Hamels in the rotation, it’s quite possible the Phillies only bring 6 relievers north in exchange for an extra bench spot. We’ll examine both possibilities.

The 5 starters are easy:

Roy Halladay
Cliff Lee
Cole Hamels
Vance Worley
Joe Blanton

The only question with the starters is whether or not Blanton gets traded, in which case Kendrick is your #5.

Bullpen

If the Phillies carry 7 relievers, it’s pretty straight forward who they will take.
Jonathan Papelbon (closer)
Chad Qualls (middle relief)
Kyle Kendrick (long relief)
Jose Contreras (setup man)
Dontrelle Willis (lefty specialist)
Antonio Bastardo (lefty specialist/set up man)
Michael Stutes (middle relief)

It’s not such an easy decision for Charlie Manuel if he elects to take only 6 relievers. They fill the first 4 spots with the guys making the most money: Papelbon, Qualls, Kendrick, and Contreras. Barring a terrible spring, Dontrelle Willis will take one of the final two spots, which leaves either Antonio Bastardo or Michael Stutes.

Bastardo will probably get the nod over Stutes since he has more experience (2 full seasons vs. 1), pitched more in 2011 (64 games vs. 57), pitched better last season (2.64 ERA vs. 3.63), and offers another lefty in the bullpen. If it’s not Bastardo or Stutes, don’t be surprised if a great spring wins the job for David Herndon, Michael Schwimer, or even Justin De Fratus.

Position players

We know who will fill 11 spots:
Carlos Ruiz (C)
Chase Utley (2B)
Jimmy Rollins (SS)
Placido Polanco (3B)
John Mayberry (LF)
Shane Victorino (CF)
Hunter Pence (RF)

Bench

Brian Schneider (C)
Ty Wigginton (1B/3B)
Laynce Nix (LF/1B)
Jim Thome (PH/1B)

Michael Martinez will likely take one of the remaining spots. Despite hitting .196 last year with no power and average speed, the Phillies like Martinez for his defense. If the Phillies carry a 13 man bench, the real battle for the one remaining spot is between Juan Pierre and Scott Podsednick.

Juan Pierre has the odds on his side since he is two years younger, has a more accomplished career, and was healthy last year. Podsednick was injured all of last season, but he hit .300 combined over the previous two campaigns and hit nearly as many homers in his last two years (13) as Pierre has in his entire career (16). They both offer speed, but have poor stealing percentages and combined to lead the league in caught stealing 9 times.

Freddy Galvis and Domonic Brown are both long shots. The Phillies just re-signed Jimmy Rollins, so the only way Galvis makes the team right now is if Rollins gets injured. Brown has a slightly better chance if he tears it up in spring training, but the Phillies feel he needs more experience in the minors.

It's not likely the Phillies would keep Pierre and Podsednick even if they carry an extended bench. In that case, we may see Galvis or Brown because they are cheaper and can be optioned to Lehigh Valley if necessary. I doubt they would keep an extra bench man, but that would make for an intriguing storyline.

Be sure to check out more great articles at Phils Baseball.

By Philsbaseball
Wednesday, 29 Feb 2012

 

More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

This day in baseball history

August 21

  • 1982

    On August 21, 1982, Rollie Fingers of the Milwaukee Brewers ...

  • 1975

    On August 21, 1975, brothers Rick and Paul Reuschel of the C ...

  • 1975

    On August 21, 1975, Tony Conigliaro of the Boston Red Sox an ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Bob Lemon

3B, Cleveland Indians

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

Vic Willis

P, Boston Braves

Read Bio
Season Profile

1963 Detroit Tigers

The Tigers were dete

Read Bio
Historical Figure

Brian McNamee

Brian Gerard McNamee is a

Read Bio
Manager Profile

Billy Herman

Chicago Cubs

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile

Arlington Stadium

The stadium was built in 1965

Read Bio
No votes yet

Comments

Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: