Ranking the Most Excruciating Losses

What’s the most difficult way a pitcher can lose a game?

For a batter, the ultimate manner to clinch a victory is to hit a grand slam, down by three runs, in the bottom of the ninth inning or later.  However, it is more difficult to rank the degree of heartache resulting from a decisive play for a pitcher.

Brant Brown, dropping the Geoff Jenkins fly ball that nearly cost the Cubs the 1998 Wild Card

Errors:  This outcome depends on the severity of the blunder.  There are several excellent examples:Bill Buckner groundballBrant Brown dropped fly ballLuis Castillo dropped infield fly ball.

Steal of Home:  The pitcher would have to fall asleep to an extremely daring base runner. A walk-off straight steal of home actually has occurred.  The immortal backup catcher for the St. Louis Cardinals, Glenn Brummer, last accomplished the feat on August 22, 1982.

Home Run:  The ultimate manner to lose a game in which the pitcher has control of the outcome.  Joe Carter and Bill Mazeroski are familiar with this result in the World Series.

Missed Umpire Call:  The Pittsburgh Pirates lost a19-inning game on July 26, 2011 by a horrible blown call at home plate to end the game.

Interference/Obstruction: Catcher’s Interference could stir an argument or two. There has been only one game in MLB history that has ended on a catcher’s-interference.  The Los Angeles Dodgers Willie Crawford was awarded a CI after his teammate Manny Mota tried to steal home in the 11th inning of a 4-4 game.  Reds catcher Johnny Bench moved out from behind home plate and stood in the base path to tag Mota and was called for interference.

Balk:  Unless “Balking” Bob Davidson is umpiring, there is little chance a game will be decided by this infraction to the rules.  The infamous John Rocker lost on a game-ending balk on May 8, 2000.

Hit By Pitch:  A lack of control is often the result of this play.  However, only a few games end on this inopportune moment per season.  The Washington Nationals clinched a victory on August 21, 2011 thanks to this decisive misguided pitch.

George Foster scores the winning run on Bob Moose’s wild pitch in the 1972 NLCS

Wild Pitch:  An errant throw to home plate can be excruciating especially when the pennant is on the line.  The 1972 NLCS ended on a Bob Moose wild pitch.

Passed Ball (3rd Strike): A passed ball is an error by the catcher but could be indirectly the fault of a pitcher who crossed up his battery mate.  Mickey Owen’s dropped third strike in Game 4 of 1941 World Series extended the game.

Walk: Bases on Balls are a direct relation to a pitcher’s inability to throw strikes.  The most egregious bases loaded walk in MLB history belongs to Kenny Rogers.  The New York Mets nearly forced Game 7 after trailing in the series 3-0.  Thanks to “The Gambler”, the Mets hopes were dashed.  To this day, Octavio Dotel should have pitched the 11th inning.

Base Hit:  Stat heads will often point to BABIP and suggest there is a certain amount of luck involved in allowing such an event to occur.  This is almost a daily occurrence at the big league level.  Arguably, Bill Bevens loss in Game 4 of the 1947 World Series might be the hardest to digest in World Series history.

Sacrifice Fly/Bunt:  Not the most dramatic way to end a game.

Fielder’s Choice: A force out is not going to make any highlight reels unless a team in unable to compete a game-ending double play.

There are many players and managers that would argue, “A loss is a loss”.  However, in some extreme circumstances some loses are actually more excruciating than others.

By qualcomm98
Tuesday, 7 Aug 2012


More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

Related Content

This day in baseball history

March 03

  • 1988

    On March 3, 1988, Los Angeles Dodgers star Kirk Gibson walks ...

  • 1987

    On March 3, 1987, former Negro Leagues standout Ray Dandridg ...

  • 1984

    On March 3, 1984, Peter Ueberroth is elected commissioner of ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Art Shamsky

1B, New York Mets

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

Roger Bresnahan

OF, Chicago Cubs

Read Bio
Season Profile

1926 Detroit Tigers

The 1920s are consid

Read Bio
Historical Figure

William Thompson


Read Bio
Manager Profile

Johnny Pesky

Boston Red Sox

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile

Arlington Stadium

The stadium was built in 1965

Read Bio
No votes yet


    Be respectful, keep it clean.
Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: