Utley to 3B? Not So Fast

Utley to 3B? Not So Fast

Utley to 3B? Not So Fast

I understand everyone’s desire to try their best to extend the career of Chase Utley. I’ve heard the suggestions, like everyone else has, for the past couple of years. “Put him in the outfield.” “Try him at first.” Aside from the obvious 250 pound issue at first in Ryan Howard, some of the suggestions made some sense.

Yesterday, Utley was spotted by WIP’s Rob Ellis and Glen Macnow fielding grounders at third base. The story quickly caught fire and Utley was confronted prior to last night’s game. To his credit, the usually tight lipped Utley confessed. It was his idea and he approached Ruben Amaro Jr. wondering if it would be an option for the team. Since then it has been reported that Utley and Amaro also discussed the outfield as an option.

The pros of Utley being able to field 3B are pretty plain. Utley wouldn’t need quite the range as he would need at 2nd which means his knees would take less of a pounding. He also wouldn’t be in the line of opposing players sliding hard into second trying to take him out. Utley could also give you more of a prototypical power third baseman. I’m not saying Utley is a power hitter, but he’ll certainly give you more pop than you’ve gotten there from Placido Polanco. It would give the Phillies greater flexibility and it would also open up a spot for Freddy Galvis, who maby fans and the organization seem to be high on. But this move would not necessarily be all good, either.

For instance, Utley played some third base in minor leagues. In 80 games at the hot corner, Utley made a staggering 28 errors. Now I’ll grant you that Utley is an experienced major leaguer now and probably a much more capable fielder, but that’s a lot of errors. The bottom line is that we’ve seen Chase Utley struggle at times with his throws from second base, how do you expect him to be able to deliver the ball all the way across the diamond with zip and precision?

Chase Utley is a true professional. I have little doubt that if Utley applied himself and worked hard over the long offseason ahead that he’d be able to field third base well. I’m just not sure that he has the arm strength to make the throws. If he can put it together, it could be a great step toward stabilizing the middle of the infield and prolonging the beloved infielder’s career. If he can’t, he could be a defensive liability on a team that has taken huge steps backward defensively this year.

Similar Posts:


Check out other great articles at Philly Sports World.

Play Our Fantasy Game Today and Try Your Hand at Winning $250 for FREE


By The Baseball Page
Friday, 31 Aug 2012


More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

This day in baseball history

September 19

  • 2007

    On September 19, 2007, New York's Andy Pettitte won his 200t ...

  • 2002

    On September 19, 2002, Kansas City Royals coach Tom Gamboa i ...

  • 1983

    On September 19, 1983, Joe Morgan of the Philadelphia Philli ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Brian Giles

DH, Pittsburg Pirates

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

George Sisler

1B, Boston Braves

Read Bio
Season Profile

Detroit Tigers 1905

  The Tigers w

Read Bio
Historical Figure

Ban Johnson

The founder of the American

Read Bio
Manager Profile

John Ward

Providence Grays

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile


Robison Field is the

Read Bio
No votes yet
Philadelphia Phillies


  • february2014 said: It a coaching decision anyway, they know what is best for the team. - Steven Wyer 10:38AM 03/19/14
Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: