- OF, P
- June 29, 1888
- 5' 11"
- 160 lbs
- Major League Debut:
- 8-06-1912 with DET
Bobby Veach was an excellent player who quite possibly would have been in the Hall of Fame had his career lasted longer. He had a career average of .310, and the Gray Ink method of Hall of Fame appraisal shows him with more points than the average Hall of Famer.
Veach spent most of his career with the Detroit Tigers at the time of Ty Cobb. Besides Cobb, he played in the Detroit outfield alongside Wahoo Sam Crawford, Harry Heilmann, and Heinie Manush, all Hall of Famers. Both the Cobb/Crawford/Veach outfield and the Cobb/Heilmann/Veach outfield have been said to be among the best of all time. Veach was the cleanup hitter on those teams, and stood among the American League leaders for runs batted in during most of his career. These great totals are in part the result of having great hitters in front of him, the afforementioned Cobb and Heilmann, but also the underrated Donie Bush who had excellent on-base percentages as the Tigers' leadoff hitter. Veach was an above-average fielder, and while he did not often lead the league in hitting categories, he was in the top ten in batting average six times, in the top ten in slugging five times, and in the top ten in RBI ten times (leading the league three times). He tended to steal around 20 bases a year.
While Veach's prime was spent during the Deadball Era, his playing style was not typical of the period: he was a slugger, who held the bat from the end of the handle and swung for power; he had no use for the type of "scientific hitting" preferred by Cobb, as he was not one to try to choke up on the bat, bunt, or hit-and-run or other strategies favored by hitters of the time. His differences with Cobb also ran to temperament as he was a laid-back person who took things in stride, in contrast to Cobb who saw life as a no-hold barred competition.
He was of Irish origin, growing up in Madisonville, KY in a family of coal miners. He was a late-comer to baseball, not starting to play until his teenage years, and not reaching the upper minors until age 24, when he had a brief stint with the Indianapolis Indians of the American Association before making his debut with the Tigers late in 1912. He spent his minor league apprenticeship mostly with the Peoria Distillers of the Three-I League and the Kankakee Kays of the Northern Association where he was a pitcher before switching to the outfield. In his first taste of The Show, he hit .342 with 15 RBI in 23 games and never looked back.
Veach's prime came from 1915 to 1921. He hit .313 with 40 doubles and 112 RBI in 1915 as the Tigers won 100 games, batted .300 in 1916 and 1917, led the league in RBI in both 1917 and 1918, then hit a whopping .355 with 191 hits, 45 doubles and 17 triples in 1919. He fell back to .307 in 1920, but drove in 113 runs. On September 17 that season, he had six bases and hit for the cycle in a game against the Boston Red Sox. After that season, Hughie Jennings, who had managed the Tigers since 1908, stepped down and was replaced by Cobb. The Georgia Peach decided that he would change Veach's attitude, forcing Harry Heilmann to yell insults to Veach throughout the 1921 season in order to keep in on edge. All three outfielders had a great season, with Veach batting .338 with 207 hits, but Cobb was still not satisfied. He tried to trade Veach to the New York Yankees in the off-season, but Veach proved he was still a star by banging out 202 hits with 126 RBI in 1922. He then hit .321 in 1923, but missed part of the season to injuries and lost playing time to a young Heinie Manush.
In January of 1924, Veach was sold to the Boston Red Sox and he finished out his career playing decently for them in 1924 - he .295 and drove in 99 runs - and for three teams in 1925. His only post-season appearance was for the Washington Senators in the 1925 World Series, when he had one at-bat. It was to be his last major league appearance. He did continue to play in the minors for a few years though, with the Toledo Mud Hens of the American Association from 1926 to 1929, and with the Jersey City Skeeters of the International League in 1930. He won the AA batting crown with a .382 average at age 40 in 1928. After hanging up his glove, he moved back to Detroit where he purchased an interest in a coal company. He underwent a serious abdominal operation in 1943 and was never fully healthy afterwards. He died at home on August 7, 1945.
The similarity scores method shows the most similar player to Veach as Dixie Walker, but perhaps a more valid comparison would be to his contemporary Sherry Magee.
- AL Hits Leader (1919)
- 2-time AL Doubles Leader (1915 & 1919)
- AL Triples Leader (1919)
- 3-time AL RBI Leader (1915, 1917 & 1918)
- 100 Runs Scored Seasons: 1 (1921)
- 100 RBI Seasons: 6 (1915, 1917 & 1919-1922)
- 200 Hits Seasons: 2 (1921 & 1922)
- Bob O'Leary: "Robert Hayes Veach", in David Jones, ed.: Deadball Stars of the American League, SABR, Potomac Books, Inc., Dulles, VA, 2006, pp. 570-572.
- Bobby Veach