TheBaseballPage.com

Manager Ed Barrow took a position with another ballclub – he moved to the New York Yankees and became the business manager (what we today call the GM). Harry Frazee hired Hugh Duffy to become the field manager of the Red Sox. Frazee was making over the ballclub, sending four more players to the Yankees in December 1920 (including future Hall of Fame pitcher Waite Hoyt), and trading Harry Hooper to the White Sox in March 1921, for Shano Collins and Nemo Leibold. Stung by the success of Ruth in New York and trading away the popular Hooper, the demonization of Frazee began. Some of the sportswriters changed their tune and started to flagellate Frazee. Nick Flately of the Boston Evening American even urged fans to boycott the team.

It wasn’t as though all his trades were without merit. No one could have predicted that Hoyt (10-12 with a 3.85 ERA in two Red Sox seasons) as going to become a Hall of Famer, and the Red Sox did get second baseman Del Pratt in the trade. He led the 1921 Red Sox in all three primary offensive statistics: a .324 batting average, 102 RBIs, and five home runs. Shano Collins was second in homers and third on the team in RBIs, and Leibold his well, too, his first year.

Sam Jones had an excellent year on the mound (23-16, 3.22) and Joe Bush had a very good one, too (16-9, 3.50). No other pitcher had a winning record. Pennock won 13, but lost 14. Two pitchers who’d come from the Yankees (Hank Thormahlen and Allen Russell – who’d had that good year in 1919) were a combined 7-18.

It’s fair to say the team was treading water. They finished 75-79, in fifth place again, with just three more wins to their credit. The Yankees won the pennant for the first time in history. The Red Sox finished 23 ½ games behind New York. And the Red Sox finished last in attendance. There just wasn’t the excitement.

By Bill Nowlin
 

More From Around the Web

Sponsored Links

This day in baseball history

September 23

  • 2000

    On September 23, 2000, former major leaguer Aurelio Rodrigue ...

  • 1983

    On September 23, 1983, Steve “Lefty” Carlton of the Phil ...

  • 1978

    On September 23, 1978, California Angels star Lyman Bostock ...

More Baseball History

Player Profile

Darryl Strawberry

OF, New York Mets

Read Bio
Hall of Fame

Sam Thompson

3B, Philadelphia Philies

Read Bio
Season Profile

2001 World Series: A

  2001 World

Read Bio
Historical Figure

Keli McGregor

 

Read Bio
Manager Profile

Al Spalding

Boston Red Stockings

Read Bio
Ballpark Profile

Camden Yards

Very much a throwback to

Read Bio
 
Tagged:
Allen Russell, Del Pratt, Ed Barrow, Hank Thormahlen, Harry Hooper, Herb Pennock, Hugh Duffy, Joe Bush, Nemo Leibold, Sam Jones, Shano Collins, Waite Hoyt

Comments

    Be respectful, keep it clean.
Login or register to post comments

Stay Connected

Share |

Today's Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: