| Player | POS |
|---|---|
| Tom Lee | P |
| Fred Andrus | P |
| Tom Lynch | P |
| Cap Anson | P |
| Fred Pfeffer | P |
| Joe Brown | P |
| Ned Williamson | P |
| John Clarkson | P |
| Larry Corcoran | P |
| Mike Corcoran | P |
| George Crosby | P |
| Fred Goldsmith | P |
| John Hibbard | P |
| King Kelly | P |
| Player | POS |
|---|---|
| Cap Anson | 1B |
| Joe Brown | 1B |
| Tom Lynch | 1B |
| John Clarkson | 1B |
| King Kelly | 1B |
| Fred Pfeffer | 2B |
| Walt Kinzie | 3B |
| Tom Burns | 3B |
| Ned Williamson | 3B |
| Sy Sutcliffe | C |
| Silver Flint | C |
| Billy Sunday | OF |
| Larry Corcoran | OF |
| Abner Dalrymple | OF |
| Fred Goldsmith | OF |
| George Gore | OF |
| Tom Lee | SS |
