| Player | POS |
|---|---|
| Stu Miller | P |
| Billy O'Dell | P |
| Gaylord Perry | P |
| Billy Pierce | P |
| Bobby Bolin | P |
| Jack Sanford | P |
| Jim Duffalo | P |
| Bob Garibaldi | P |
| Don Larsen | P |
| Dick LeMay | P |
| Juan Marichal | P |
| Mike McCormick | P |
| Player | POS |
|---|---|
| Willie McCovey | 1B |
| Orlando Cepeda | 1B |
| Dick Phillips | 1B |
| Chuck Hiller | 2B |
| Manny Mota | 2B |
| Ernie Bowman | 2B |
| Harvey Kuenn | 3B |
| Jim Davenport | 3B |
| Tom Haller | C |
| Joe Pignatano | C |
| Ed Bailey | C |
| John Orsino | C |
| Willie Mays | CF |
| Felipe Alou | CF |
| Matty Alou | CF |
| Bob Nieman | LF |
| Carl Boles | LF |
| Jose Pagan | SS |
| Cap Peterson | SS |
