TheBaseballPage.com

2 years 6 weeks ago

Posted on March 03, 2012 by Dan Flaherty

Major League Baseball has expanded the postseason to 10 teams, adding an extra wild-card in each league. The new format will require the two wild-card teams in each league to play a one-game playoff for the right to join the three other division winners in the Division Series. I applaud this move wholeheartedly while acknowledging that it might have effects on the Red Sox that are less than ideal.

The American League East has basically owned the wild-card spot since its inception in 1995 (actually the inception was for 1994 but the strike prevented it from coming to fruition). Other than a three-year stretch from 2000-02 when the AL West produced two playoff teams each year and 2006 when the Central grabbed two berths, the wild-card team has come out of the AL East. The Red Sox have gotten into the playoffs via this route in 1998-99, 2003-05 and 2008-09. Only in 1995 and 2007 did Boston enter the postseason as the winners of the AL East—though we have to note that in 2005 they played the Yankees to a co-championship in the AL East and were just seeded lower based on the head-to-head tiebreaker.

Those seven wild-card berths have proven fruitful for Boston, most notably in 2004 when they won their historic World Series title. The Sox reached also reached the ALCS in 1999, 2003 and 2008. So a majority of their wild-card trips have resulted in advancement. That’s going to be much more difficult to do under the current format.

How might the 1999 Red Sox have fared if Pedro Martinez would have had to pitch a one-game playoff against Oakland? Even if the Sox win, Pedro’s availability is reduced for what was a battle against Cleveland to reach the ALCS? The same goes in 2003 when Pedro would have gotten the ball against Seattle. Again, even if the Sox win, Pedro’s not around to pitch twice in the Division Series against Oakland, one of which was a win in the decisive Game 5. Most alarmingly, what if Curt Schilling has to in a one-game playoff in 2004 against Texas? Here, I don’t think it would have been a problem to recover, because the pitching depth was better…but there’s always that possibility you might actually lose.

Whether it’s losing the one-game playoff outright or simply losing your best pitcher to start the Division Series, there’s no question that being the wild-card won’t be what it used to. But I think that’s a good thing. And who’s to say that the 2004 Red Sox couldn’t have caught the Yankees in the AL East if there would have been these kind of stakes? Or that the veteran experience of the 2008 Sox might not have carried them past the youthful Tampa Bay Rays? Teams manage and play for what’s actually at stake, and what was at stake in what should have been compelling AL East races in 1999, 2003, 2007 & 2008 was absolutely nothing. (In the other years the race wasn’t close or in the case of 2005, you had a third team in the mix making the wild-card less of a sure thing).

If the Boston Red Sox are playing the New York Yankees in early September and the teams are separated by a game or two in the standings, I want to feel like everything’s on the line. I don’t want to be wondering if the teams really care who finishes first—or if even I should care. The new format won’t be everything on the line, but it will sure guarantee teams care, and that’s an undeniably good thing.

Boston Sports Now and Then's Blog

2 years 6 weeks ago
Posted on March 03, 2012 by Dan Flaherty Major League Baseball has expanded the postseason to 10 teams, adding an extra wild-card in each league. The new format will require the two wild-card teams in each league to play a one-game playoff for the right to join the three other division winners in... Read more.
2 years 7 weeks ago
BY DAN FLAHERTY Last year a prominent American League East team went into spring training answering questions about who would be their fourth and fifth starters. That team came out of the season as AL East champs. Unfortunately it was the New York Yankees, but with the Boston Red Sox facing similar... Read more.
2 years 7 weeks ago
BY DAN FLAHERTY To say new Boston Red Sox manager Bobby Valentine is a little different than Terry Francona is to say that Rex Ryan has a somewhat different media approach than Bill Belichick.  Well, perhaps, the Valentine-Francona gap isn’t that large, but it is something... Read more.
2 years 8 weeks ago
Posted on February 20, 2012 by Dan Flaherty The night was October 16, 2004 and a game, and another season was slipping away from the Boston Red Sox. Already trailing the New York Yankees two games to none in the American League Championship Series, the pitching in Game 3 was serving up batting... Read more.
2 years 11 weeks ago
Posted on January 30, 2012 by Erik Venskus Last season the Boston Red Sox won 90 games and finished 1 game out of the wild card for a spot in the post season.  When you take out the first and last months of the season they were the best team in all of baseball.  They had the best... Read more.
2 years 12 weeks ago
Posted on January 19, 2012 by Erik Venskus We’ve heard a lot about Josh Beckett and Jon Lester, who struggled to give the Sox clutch starts late in the season and then were tar and feathered by the media for their beer and chicken scandal, since the end of the season.  We’ve heard a lot about... Read more.
This day in baseball history

April 19

  • 1997

    On April 19, 1997, a major league game is played in Hawaii f ...

  • 1984

    On April 19, 1984, the Detroit Tigers suffer their first los ...

  • 1981

    On April 19, 1981, the Oakland Athletics set a modern day re ...

More Baseball History

Poll

Will Red Sox Repeat in 2014: